EIFS: Construction efficiency or construction concern?

April 15, 2019 - by Bryan T. Maphet, Andrew Feenstra burning building.jpg

What is EIFS?

Exterior Insulation and Finish System (EIFS) is a non-load bearing wall cladding system comprised of rigid insulation panels coated with a field-applied synthetic stucco. The insulation panels can be mechanically or adhesively attached to substrates as diverse as concrete block, wood sheathing, gypsum board, metal panels and more. It is light weight and can cover large areas with fewer control joints than conventional stucco. The expanded polystyrene (EPS) foam that the rigid insulation panels are made of is on the higher end of thermal efficiency per inch of thickness relative to the other insulation products currently on the market.

Because the foam is molded, it comes in a wide variety of thicknesses and shapes, while also being easily cut to fit building forms and features. The coatings come in a wide variety of colors and textures, allowing EIFS to fit both classic and contemporary building designs.

Although it’s an increasingly popular cladding technique, it comes with a very real concern: flammability.

Where is EIFS most prevalent?

Before we jump into what makes it combustible, let’s back up a bit and understand where this material originated.

EIFS was developed in Europe in the 1960's and was designed to provide the European construction market with a means to insulate older brick buildings without taking valuable interior space and, at the same time, enhancing their appearance. EIFS was introduced to North America in 1969 and marketed under the name Dryvit®--originally used on commercial buildings such as offices, shopping centers, apartments, and hotels. The popularity of EIFS increased greatly during that time due to the oil crisis and EIFS’s potential for contributing to energy efficiency. Eventually, prices came down and EIFS became attractive for more widespread use in single-family residences.

Currently, EIFS enjoys worldwide use and is gaining popularity with the continuous insulation movement. Yet, the concerns for insurers continue.

Why is EIFS flammable?

While EIFS has had a reputation for moisture-related issues, it also has flammability concerns. Such concerns lead to recommendations for insurers to classify EIFS as combustible for rating purposes.

Polystyrene foam is a thermoplastic material – a petroleum-derived plastic – which means it will melt and flow when heated at lower temperatures relative to other building materials. Though EIFS does include the synthetic stucco coating to prevent direct ignition, the insulation panels can be deformed by heat and undermine the stucco coating. In locations or uses where fires are of greater concern, several EIFS manufacturers have added flame retardants to the foam to reduce its flame spread rating.

Ignition and Fire Spread involving EIFS

Several factors can affect the actual performance of EIFS in a fire situation. Material defects, poor workmanship, impact damage, installation errors, and other factors that expose the insulation are among the leading causes of fire. According to White and Delichatsios, these fires can be ignited in one of two possible ways:

  • Fires external to the building (other burning buildings, external ground fires).
  • Fires internal to the building that have resulted in breaking the windows and ejecting flames onto the facade.

Once ignited, mechanisms of fire spread include:

  • Spread to interior or level above through openings such as windows, causing secondary interior fires resulting in level-to-level fire spread (i.e. leap frogging).
  • Across the external surface of the facade assembly, if combustible.
  • Within an internal vertical cavity/air gap or internal insulation layer.
  • Through failures or deficiencies of any fire barriers, if present – particularly at the junction of the floor with the external wall.
  • Heat flux impacts causing degradation/separation of non-combustible external cladding (loss of integrity), thus exposing an internal core.
  • Fallen burning debris or downward fire spread causing secondary external fires to lower (ground) levels.
  • Channeling of convective heat and re-radiation between surfaces such as corners or in channels, accelerating flame spread.

The Future of EIFS

Many combustible materials are used today in commercial exterior wall assemblies for a number of reasons, but most commonly to resist water intrusion, improve energy performance with improved insulation, and to allow for design flexibility. However, the combustibility of the assembly components has proven to be a fire hazard; the insulation component, polystyrene foam, alone promotes flame spread when melted.

There have been a number of documented fire incidents involving combustible exterior walls, and EIFS should be evaluated as a possible reason. Subrogation matters and high-dollar claims have all been experienced due to this material. How it will change or adapt in the future to help mitigate these issues is unknown. But what we do know is, until that day happens, we need to evaluate property with due diligence when EIFS is present.

About the Authors

Bryan Maphet is Executive Vice President, Subrogation with Envista Forensics and has an extensive background in fire and explosion investigations across the United States and throughout numerous foreign countries. He has personally worked or supervised more than 7,800 investigations and has over 12,000 hours of on-site experience. He has experience as an expert witness for testimonies in fire causation and spread, explosions, and insurance fraud in various State and Federal Courts within the United States and over 19 foreign countries. He has also testified as an expert witness for the United States Justice Department in a Terrorist Trial.

Andrew Feenstra, PE is a Practice Group Leader, Building Envelopes at Envista Forensics. He is a Project Engineer with nearly 15 years of engineering and architectural experience – most of which is forensic experience investigating building damage. Though he has had residential and commercial structural design experience in steel, concrete, and timber materials, it is his residential and commercial architectural design experience that has greatly informed his focus on building enclosures and their associated failures – particularly with regards to moisture-related damage. He has performed construction inspections for both structural and architectural elements and been involved in the development and certification of green buildings. 

 

Sources:

Canadian Underwriter. Don’t get burned rating EIFS. Dec. 1, 2006. https://www.canadianunderwriter.ca/features/don-t-get-burned-rating-e-i-f-s/

Fire Hazards of Exterior Wall Assemblies Containing Combustible Components. White and Delichatsios. 2014.

Willis. EIFS: When F is for Flammable. December 2008.

 



About the Authors

Bryan T. Maphet

Bryan is EVP, Subrogation with an extensive background in large, complex losses, many of which concerning matters of subrogation. He has extensive experience in fire investigation losses across the globe, and has personally supervised more than 7,800 investigations. He has also been an expert witness for testimonies in fire causation and spread, explosions and insurance fraud in various State and Federal courts in the United States, as well as 19 other countries.

Bryan T. Maphet

Andrew Feenstra

Andrew is a P.E. with 15 years of engineering, architectural and forensic investigation experience. He has residential and commercial structural design knowledge in steel, concrete, and timber. His architectural design experience informed his focus on building enclosures and their associated failures – particularly concerning moisture-related damage. Andrew has also been involved in the development and certification of green buildings.

Andrew Feenstra

← View All Blog